In the world of CQC inspections, sometimes the toughest lessons come from experience. One of our Harmony CQC Confidence members recently shared an eye-opening story that’s worth every practice manager’s attention.
“We thought we had everything covered – risk assessments for the reception team, clear notes, a side room for private discussions. Then came the question: who would speak with the patient in that private room? When we replied ‘a member of the reception team’, we’d walked straight into a safeguarding trap. The CQC had us – and rightly so.”
That small detail – who interacts with patients privately – triggered a safeguarding concern. The practice handled it brilliantly on the spot, updating their policy so that only DBS-checked staff meet patients in private. The issue never made it into the report. But the learning point is powerful: if your reception or admin staff have even occasional one-to-one contact with patients, DBS checks are essential.
Why DBS for All Makes Sense
Many practices still hesitate over whether to obtain DBS checks for non-clinical staff. The argument often hinges on perceived role boundaries — “they don’t provide care,” or “they only handle admin tasks.” But as this real example shows, the moment those roles intersect with patient access or confidentiality, the risk changes.
Here’s the key:
If your staff support the provision of care, have access to patient records, or interact with patients privately, they fall within DBS eligibility.
Run the NHS Employers DBS Eligibility Tool and you’ll find this question:
“Will the individual be providing a health service that gives them access to persons in receipt of health services as part of their normal duties?”
The tool clarifies that this includes non-clinical roles such as receptionists — anyone whose normal duties involve contact with patients.
The Hidden Risk: Access to Records
Even if a receptionist never sits alone with a patient, they likely have access to clinical systems. That access alone introduces a safeguarding element.
Through records, an individual could:
- Identify vulnerable patients.
- Access sensitive information.
- Exploit perceived authority or knowledge.
The DBS check is not about mistrusting your team — it’s about ensuring the safety net is in place to protect patients and your practice.
Safeguarding Is a System, Not a Checkbox
A DBS check is just one part of a much wider safeguarding process. It helps prevent unsuitable individuals from entering your workforce, but it doesn’t detect every risk. That’s why robust supervision, whistleblowing processes, and ongoing safeguarding training remain equally critical.
Think of the DBS as the front door — it filters out those who shouldn’t enter.
Your wider safeguarding culture is what keeps everyone safe once they’re inside.
Before Your Next CQC Visit:
Take time to:
- Review your safeguarding policy.
- Revisit your risk assessments, especially for reception and admin roles.
- Cross-check your DBS eligibility using the NHS Employers tool.
- Read the CQC’s Mythbuster on DBS checks to ensure your reasoning aligns with current guidance.
And if in doubt? Lean toward safety. As one of our community members wisely put it:
“Having been caught out once, I now lean toward having a DBS for all.”
Want more informative content like this?
Join our free Harmony CQC Community here: